Hey Jeremy;
Thanks for the cartoon - it's a pretty good picture of the state of the world today.
I am wondering if perhaps the "paradox" is a puzzle partly due to our use of the word "responsibility" and its common meaning. For example, in our best practices work, we separate "responsibility" from "accountability". That allows a definition of responsibility that include performing the action, the doing of something, for which we are responsible. That includes looking after ourselves, and doing what is necessary to safeguard and enhance our state of being. Accountability is the next piece, where one is concerned with the quality of that work - the ouput or result. As a manager, for example, I can assign responsibility for doing work to someone, and maintain accountability for the success of that, or also assign accountability.
Accordingly we are all responsible for ourselves, and should be accountable for the well being of others (as smart, well developed citizens). In the cartoon, the fellows in the bow are demonstrating responsibility for themselves (staying dry, preserving their energy) but no accountability to the quality of the outcome of the safety of the boat (the high probability that the boat will sink without their effort).
Thoughts?
Cheers, Paul